2007 Game 1 Young Gunz 4   Goodfellas 45 Game 2 Goodfellas 46   Young Gunz 8   Goodfellas win series 2-0	2006 Game 1 SWAT 10   Knights 16 Game 2 Knights 6   SWAT 10 Game 3 SWAT 3   Knights 12 Knights win series 2-1
2005 Game 1 Griffins 4   Grand Clinic 18 Game 2 Grand Clinic 18   Griffins 8   Grand Clinic wins series 2-0	2004 Game 1 Pythons 7   Goodfellas 12 Game 2 Goodfellas 20   Pythons 6   Goodfellas win series 2-0
2003 Game 1 Grand Clinic 15   Goodfellas 25 Game 2 Goodfellas 9   Grand Clinic 18 Game 3 Grand Clinic 2   Goodfellas 18 Goodfellas win series 2-1	2002 Game 1 Young Gunz 17   Grand Clinic 9 Game 2 Grand Clinic 15   Young Gunz 3 Game 3 Young Gunz 0   Grand Clinic 12 Grand Clinic wins series 2-1
2001 Game 1 Griffins 8   Goodfellas 9, 8inn Game 2 Goodfellas 19   Griffins 7   Goodfellas win series 2-0	2000 Game 1 Griffins 8   Goodfellas 9, 8inn Game 2 Goodfellas 19   Griffins 7   Goodfellas win series 2-0
1999 Puds   Puds defeat Goodfellas and win series 2-0	1998 Puds   *Goodfellas forfeit
1997 Rangers   Rangers defeat Goodfellas 9-4	1996 Rangers   Rangers defeat Goodfellas 26-9
1995 Dragons   Dragons Defeat Most Wanted	1994 Dragons   Dragons defeat Most Wanted